Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Cognitive dissonance FTW

A friend who owns a few preschools was telling me a story about some of the "hippie" kids. Since hand washing is on the curriculum, the kids have to learn the "proper" way to wash their hands. Basically it just involves more time, a lot of soap and some running water at the beginning and end. (It’s well established that hand washing, in and of itself, can prevent a number of infections and illnesses. FYI: Not the flu, which is a respiratory infection.)

That, of course, isn't what their parents teach. "Hippie" parents teach that using too much water for hand washing (say, more than a second) kills the earth. Disease be damned.

The cognitive dissonance pops up when, on parents night, the kids have to demonstrate what they've learned. That puts the kids in a tricky situation. Do the kids do it wrong according to their teacher or their parent?

I don't remember having to deal with that kind of cognitive dissonance until I was much older. Like High School-aged. Especially at such an early age (3-6) and for something as simple as hand washing. (My parents taught me to do it. It stuck until I was old enough to decide if it was important. I agreed with it at that point, and now I look down my nose at the unclean people who don't wash their hands after they go to the bathroom.)

Nowadays, kids don't have it that easy. Hell, nobody does. Every choice is polarizing. Even choices that used to be simple and straightforward, like grocery or clothes shopping, have becoming these meaningful choices. Do you support sweat shops? Factory farming? Corn subsidies? Corn syrup? A debt-based economy?

No matter what you choose, there is bound to be someone who deeply believes that your choice is immoral. And they can't all be wrong.

Labels:

3 Comments:

Blogger Unknown said...

Isn't it counterproductive to wash hands under running water? I thought that one is to wet hands, make a lather and scrub all surfaces, and then rinse. If the water is running over hands the entire time, won't it rinse away the soap before it has had a chance to dissolve and wash all the funk away? Read your link carefully...

That is why at lot of public places have switched to the 2-3 second infra-red sensor faucets, I thought--This seems to be good water management, can save a lot of gallons of freshwater.

I am not shaking the hand of a child again, until this is resolved!

Wed Feb 24, 09:44:00 PM MST  
Blogger b r christensen said...

i don't know that this is a new problem. kids have been deciding that what they've learned from their parents is true or bull**** for a long time now.

p.s. damn hippies. they're obviously wrong, they're hippies. they probably believe in fair trade and gravity too.

Thu Feb 25, 11:14:00 AM MST  
Blogger L-to-the-Del said...

I think it is worse to spread disease than to waste a small amount of water. Do it for the "greater good".

Tue Mar 02, 09:09:00 AM MST  

Post a Comment

<< Home