A Recent History of an Academy in Accuracy and Error
2011 - The Artist
should have been: well, I'd probably go with A Separation. Maybe a cop-out since it won best foreign film, but Life is Beautiful was nominated for best picture. . . .
also better than The Artist: better not to go down that rabbit hole again.
2010 - The King's Speech
should have been: Inception.
also better than the King's Speech: The Fighter, 127 Hours, Animal Kingdom, Blue Valentine
2009 - The Hurt Locker
should have been: The Hurt Locker. Some might say Inglourious Basterds, but not me, I'm with the Academy on this one.
2008 - Slumdog Millionaire
should have been: The Dark Knight [lots of Nolan love from me so far, maybe it's snub bias]
also better than Slumdog: oof. . . too many, Frost/Nixon, Milk, Vicky Cristina Barcelona, Wall-E . . .
2007 - No Country for Old Men
should have been: No Country for Old Men. I also would have accepted There Will Be Blood.
2006 - The Departed
should have been: Children of Men. I do love me some Marky Mark, but Children of Men is up there as the best film of the decade for me. (It wasn't nominated.)
also better than The Departed: not much, any year.
2005 - Crash
should have been: tough choice between Brokeback, Sin City, and A History of Violence for me. I'd probably go with A History of Violence as my personal favorite of the year, but certainly wouldn't begrudge the award going to Brokeback Mountain.
also better than Crash: The gum on the bottom of the seat at the theater. Oh my god, in a great year for film this has to be one of the worst Best Picture selections ever. The list of movies better than Crash released in '05 is nearly as long as the list of movies released in '05. A refresher on some of the better ones: Sin City, Brokeback Mountain, Layer Cake, The 40 Year Old Virgin, Kung Fu Hustle, The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada, Oldboy, Murderball, Grizzly Man, Goodnight and Good Luck, Batman Begins, Syriana, The Constant Gardener, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Junebug, Howl's Moving Castle, Millions, Capote, Walk the Line, Match Point, Hustle & Flow. . . .
This brings us to Logan's worst year nomination: 2004 - Million Dollar Baby
should have been: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
also better: again too many. I'd go with The Motorcycle Diaries, Hotel Rwanda, Kinsey, House of Flying Daggers, Maria Full of Grace, Sideways, Kill Bill vol. 2, Spider-Man 2, Before Sunset.
2003 - Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
should have been: City of God. I don't blame the Academy for finally recognizing a Lord of the Rings film in '03 but damn, City of God.
also better: 21 Grams, Lost in Translation.
2002 - Chicago
should have been: Why didn't you give the Oscar to Lord of the Rings this year instead of this Chicago bullshit? Are you kidding? Chicago? I mean Punch Drunk Love would have been my choice, but at least go with Lord of the Rings over Chicago.
also better: my dung. Incidentally, Y tu mama tambien, Talk to Her, Hero, Adaptation.
2001 - A Beautiful Mind
should have been: Memento.
also better: Mulholland Drive, Lord of the Rings 1, Amelie, The Devil's Backbone, The Royal Tennanbaums, Oceans Eleven, Spy Kids, Black Hawk Down. . . more.
2000 - Gladiator
should have been: Amores Perros.
also better: nothing really, I don't really mind Gladiator winning, but Amores Perros is another of my favorite films of the decade, so I'd go with that.
I'll stop there.