Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Tomorrow is a latter day.


With a little dumb luck I stumbled into tickets to Broadway's hottest new show.

When I bought my tickets earlier this year, I certainly didn't imagine that a musical from the creators of South Park based around Mormonism would appeal to anybody but me. But lo and behold, just days after the Tony Awards I was having to seriously consider whether or not to unload my tickets for a profit of $500 a piece.

In the end, I made the somewhat indefensible financial decision of seeing the show. I guess my rationale was that the older I get the more important novel experiences are to me. Plus I earned bagging rights for the next few months.

After bearing witness to The Book of Mormon, I can see why this show got so popular.

As you might expect, the musical is irreverently funny. Most of the best jokes would not be quotable in the Arts section of the New York Times.

As you might not expect, it is quite reverential to the tropes of Broadway. Although the content is subversive, the form is not: this is a gloriously infectious musical.

Still, I am also quite puzzled as to how this show got so popular.

Given the press blitz that surrounded the premiere, I expected the show to pull its punches -- at least in contrast to the South Park episode. After all, one of the talking points in all the interviews was how even Mormons who attended the show thought it was funny.

I'm not quite sure I buy that.

Sure there are quite a few laughs generated from the fish out of water story-arc and the City Weekly reviewer got it right when he remarked that quite a few of these songs aren't all that far removed from what you find in Saturday's Warrior.

But a vast majority of the jokes come directly at the expense of Mormon faith. And Parker and Stone don't even take aim at the most obvious targets (polygamy or Jesus Jammy jokes): they simply present Mormon spiritual beliefs in a fairly didactic manner and let their intrinsic ludicrousness act as the joke itself.

If I were Mormon, I would probably be pretty bummed about the whole affair.

At its heart, The Book of Mormon seems to side with Nietzsche that man needs myth - whether it be Christianity or Tolkenism - for life and that any act of faith will be absurd. Thus the same manner of criticism could be leveled at any religion: one's spiritual beliefs will always be laughable to those who don't share them.

But I don't think The Book of Mormon would have been so successful if it were about, let's say, Scientology.

The musical can be both popular and transgressive due to Mormonism being so perfectly situated between the canny and the uncanny for Christians. It's the narcissism of minor differences: "We both believe that Jesus died and was resurrected but you believe that he once visited America... How silly!" Thus the lady two rows down from me could both laugh along with the musical but also be doing her rosaries at the same time.

That The Book of Mormon is able to straddle such a precarious line makes it all that more miraculous.

[Side note: the Salt Lake City set has quite a few easter eggs for the Utah crew but it also features an inexplicable Wendy's/Tim Horton's sign. Does such a location exist in the Mountain Time Zone or is this simply a heretical errata?]

3 Comments:

Blogger M S Martinez said...

You are right. No Tim Horton's here. Just lots of Wendy's.

And I agree. Some of the songs are so raunchy, that I can't imagine any actual Mormons liking the show.

I wonder how it will go down when it starts touring and stops here in Salt Lake.

Interesting sidenote. We went to see Ira Glass on Saturday and he couldn't resist playing a few bits from The Book of Mormon.

Wed Jun 29, 07:18:00 AM GMT-7  
Blogger b r christensen said...

The show sounds great, I'm jealous. Also a really nice post, thanks.

I haven't seen the show, but I've listened to the soundtrack, and I'm pretty sure I know quite a few Mormons who I believe would find it funny.

There are, believe it or not, a good number of Mormons who are aware that their beliefs are ludicrous. How they maintain their faith and self-awareness is (obviously) beyond me, but they mange somehow.

It absolutely makes sense to me that the self-selected group of Mormons who attend The Book of Mormon would mostly enjoy it. Noone who buys a ticket is expecting the Hill Cumorah pageant. I would suspect that most who go are already familiar with Parker and Stone, are fans of them in general, and have a good idea of what they're in for.

My guess anyway.

Wed Jun 29, 11:59:00 AM GMT-7  
Blogger M S Martinez said...

(I'm also just going off of my many listens to the soundtrack, but) Yeah, I wasn't trying to say that I didn't think that there are any Mormons who would see/enjoy the show.

For me, I am thinking of someone more like my Mom. She wouldn't like it as a whole because of the vulgarity. I actually think that the vulgarity would be more a deterrent than the depictions of the Mormons. The play seems to try very hard to make the missionaries naive idealists, and not just stupid morons.

Wed Jun 29, 01:27:00 PM GMT-7  

Post a Comment

<< Home